Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

… Euro Today R$ 6,48

Citizenship

Daughter’s case takes Italian citizen living in Portugal to the European Commission over citizenship reform

Complaint sent to Ursula von der Leyen and the presidents of Italy and Portugal opens a new institutional front against the Tajani Decree and questions its effects on the families of European citizens living abroad.

Caso de filha nascida em Portugal leva cidadão italiano à Comissão Europeia em nova contestação ao Decreto Tajani.

Italy’s 2025 citizenship reform has faced a new challenge. An Italian citizen living in Portugal filed a formal complaint with the European Commission, questioning the effects of the so-called Tajani Decree on his minor daughter, who was born in Portuguese territory after the new rules took effect.

The case involves a citizen whose Italian citizenship by descent was formally recognized before March 28, 2025. He retains Italian status and, consequently, status as a European Union citizen. The dispute concerns the consequences of the legislative change for his daughter, who did not obtain recognition of Italian citizenship by birth.

The complaint was sent by certified electronic mail (PEC) on Nov. 16, 2026. Attorney Luis Roberto Lorenzato, a former member of the Italian Parliament, signed the document as the citizen’s legal representative.

In addition to European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, the communication was sent to Italian President Sergio Mattarella and Portuguese President António José Seguro. According to the PEC itself, those authorities were notified solely for institutional awareness. The European Commission remains the sole recipient of the formal requests.

Italian father, daughter without citizenship recognition

According to the complaint, the girl was born in Portugal after the entry into force of Decree-Law No. 36/2025, converted into Law No. 74/2025.

Under the previous rules, parentage from an Italian citizen generally constituted grounds for acquiring citizenship from birth, regardless of the country where the child was born.

Advertisement

The reform introduced Article 3-bis into Law No. 91/1992, establishing new conditions for recognizing citizenship by descent for people born abroad who also hold another nationality.

The exceptions include situations involving first- or second-degree ascendants who are exclusively Italian, and one parent’s residence in Italy for at least two continuous years after acquiring Italian citizenship and before the child’s birth.

The representative says the family does not fall within the applicable exceptions. Therefore, the girl would not have acquired Italian citizenship by birth when she was born.

The complaint emphasizes that the reform did not strip the father of his citizenship, but changed the conditions for passing it on to children born abroad.

In presenting the specific case, the document asks the European Commission:

“How can effective protection of the rights of a girl born in European Union territory, the daughter of an Italian citizen by birth who exercises freedom of movement, be ensured when her citizenship has not yet been fully determined and the legislation of her father’s member state may exclude her from Italian citizenship by birth?”

Free translation of the excerpt from the complaint, originally drafted in Italian.

The child’s documentary status

The PEC also addresses the girl’s nationality. According to the complainant, she has a Portuguese birth record, but currently does not have an Italian, Brazilian or Portuguese passport.

Advertisement

Both parents hold Brazilian citizenship. The document states that the birth was not registered with Brazilian consular authorities and provides a certificate of no naturalization issued by Brazil’s Ministry of Justice on June 20, 2026.

The certificate, however, establishes only that there is no record of naturalization. It does not demonstrate that the child did not acquire Brazilian nationality by birth.

The complaint itself acknowledges this distinction and says the girl’s situation must be clarified individually. It also does not classify her as stateless.

The representative requests that the Commission examine the consequences of the lack of documentary clarity regarding nationality for the protection of the child’s rights and for the family situation.

New front against the Tajani Decree

The legal argument seeks to take the discussion beyond national authority over citizenship.

The complaint invokes Articles 20 and 21 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), which address European citizenship and freedom of movement and residence in member states.

Advertisement

The argument presented is that Italian legislation must also be examined for the effects it may have on a European citizen who lives in another EU country and starts a family in that territory.

The document also mentions Directive 2004/38/EC and Articles 7 and 24 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, concerning family life and the protection of children’s rights.

The PEC acknowledges that the daughter may have derivative residence rights as a family member of a European citizen, even without holding citizenship of a member state. The question concerns the difference between that status and that of a European citizen from birth.

Another argument involves the consequences for future generations. If the girl later acquires citizenship through the benefit-of-law procedure, she will not have the same legal status as an Italian citizen by birth. This could affect the conditions for passing citizenship on to her own children.

Case joins question already referred to European justice

The new initiative comes as another dispute over the Tajani Decree is already before the Court of Justice of the European Union.

In July 2026, Italy’s Constitutional Court referred, through Order No. 147/2026, a preliminary question to the European court regarding the compatibility of Article 3-bis of Law No. 91/1992 with Article 9 of the Treaty on European Union and Article 20 of the TFEU.

The dispute referred to the Court of Justice concerns the application of restrictions to people born abroad before March 28, 2025.

The case now brought before the European Commission has a different time frame: It involves a child born after the reform took effect, the daughter of an Italian citizen whose recognition had already occurred previously.

These are distinct situations, although they are related to the same legislation.

What can the European Commission do?

The complaint asks Brussels to examine the compatibility of Italian legislation with EU law, seek clarification from authorities in Rome and assess the possibility of opening infringement proceedings under Article 258 of the TFEU.

Sending the PEC does not mean that the Commission has opened an investigation or recognized a violation of the treaties. The institution will have to assess the complaint and decide whether to proceed with its review.

Any infringement proceedings would aim to correct a possible general incompatibility between Italian legislation and European law. They would not automatically grant citizenship to the child or directly resolve the family’s individual situation.

The initiative adds a new institutional front to the challenge against the Tajani Decree. The debate is no longer focused exclusively on the rules for passing citizenship by descent and also begins to question the reform’s possible effects on the family life of a European citizen living in another member state.

See the full document:

Newsletter

Últimas do Italianismo

Todo dia, às 18h, um resumo do que aconteceu na Itália direto no seu e-mail.

Newsletter — Últimas do Italianismo

É gratuito e você cancela quando quiser.

Italianismo Specials

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More stories:

Citizenship

Law No. 11/2026 limits appointments for Italian citizenship at consulates. In São Paulo, procedures completed in 2025 will determine the annual cap.

Citizenship

The organization that is now demanding explanations from Luis Cavalieri was praising its closer ties with the consulate less than two months ago. The...

Citizenship

An agreement among center-left parties provides for citizenship for children born in Italy with at least one parent who has lived in the country...

Citizenship

Association challenges statements by the consul in Porto Alegre, recalls consular waiting lists and seeks clarification about descendants awaiting service.