Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

… Euro Today R$ 6,29

Citizenship

‘The state was the one asleep at the wheel’: Natitaliani rebuts Italian consul and responds to criticism of descendants

Association challenges statements by the consul in Porto Alegre, recalls consular waiting lists and seeks clarification about descendants awaiting service.

“A impressão que tivemos na Itália é que muita gente realmente só queria a cidadania para passear" | Foto: Foto: Bettina Gehm/Grupo RBS

The Natitaliani Association sent an open letter to Italy’s consul general in Porto Alegre, Luis Cavalieri, in response to statements by the diplomat published by the newspaper Pioneiro on November 16, 2026. The organization challenged the assertion that descendants of Italians had “missed the boat” by waiting to seek citizenship recognition decades after their ancestors arrived in Brazil.

Also sent to Italy’s ambassador to Brazil, the Italian Foreign Ministry (MAECI), the Comites of Rio Grande do Sul and the press, the letter is signed by Daniel Taddone, president of Natitaliani, and attorney Flavia Helena Meirelles Di Pilla, the association’s legal coordinator.

In the interview with Pioneiro, Cavalieri questioned why descendants of Italians whose ancestors arrived in Brazil about 150 years ago were only now seeking recognition. He also mentioned the widespread impression in Italy that many seek citizenship only “to travel.”

‘Who was really asleep at the wheel?’ association asks

Natitaliani says that thousands of descendants were already registered on consular waiting lists and awaiting service. To support its argument, the letter recalls that in June 2005, the Paraná-Santa Catarina Comites reportedly informed then-Minister Mirko Tremaglia that about 85,000 people were awaiting service in Curitiba alone.

The organization also recalls that in 2007, applicants spent the night on the street to obtain document legalization. “These compatriots, Mr. Consul, were not asleep at the wheel: they were sleeping on the sidewalk in front of an Italian consular office,” the letter states.

Among other episodes, the association mentions a task force announced by the Farnesina in 2008 and 2009 to reduce waiting lists in South America and the commitment made by the Consulate in Porto Alegre in March 2018 to clear its waiting list by the end of 2020.

Advertisement

The letter also cites more than 237,000 people awaiting service at Brazilian consulates in July 2019. For Porto Alegre, it provides an estimate of approximately 120,000 people in line in March 2025, when calls had reached numbers between 16,001 and 17,000. The data are attributed to the association’s statement.

Criticism of Prenot@mi and citizenship reform

Natitaliani also criticizes the operation of Prenot@mi and the actions of intermediaries who resold appointments. The organization argues that negligence cannot be attributed to people who repeatedly tried to obtain an appointment but were not served.

On the legal front, the association cites decisions by the Joint Sections of the Court of Cassation and maintains that, before the 2025 reform, there was no general deadline for seeking recognition of citizenship by descent. It therefore considers it unfair to hold responsible those who were on a consular waiting list when the new rules took effect.

The letter also mentions Ordinance No. 147/2026 of the Italian Constitutional Court, which referred questions concerning the compatibility of the new rules with European Union law to the Court of Justice of the European Union. The referral does not represent a final decision on the law’s validity.

Organization seeks clarification from consul

The association also considers unfair the idea that many descendants seek citizenship only to travel. In the letter, it highlights the preservation of language, traditions and family memory by Italian communities in Brazil, as well as the cultural heritage represented by Talian.

Finally, Natitaliani asks Cavalieri to publicly clarify his statements and release data on people who were on the waiting list of the Consulate in Porto Alegre and had not yet been called by March 27, 2025. It also requests information on pending transcription and AIRE registration matters, as well as a meeting with the consul general.

The letter concludes: “Citizenship is certainly a serious matter; equally serious is the state’s duty to respond to those who request it within the time frames established by the law itself.”

Newsletter

Últimas do Italianismo

Todo dia, às 18h, um resumo do que aconteceu na Itália direto no seu e-mail.

Newsletter — Últimas do Italianismo

É gratuito e você cancela quando quiser.

Italianismo Specials

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More stories:

Uncategorized

ISTAT documents show that research on the Italian population abroad had already been planned before the 2025 reform.

Uncategorized

The country recorded an 11.45% increase in the survey, virtually tied with Portugal and Spain. ISTAT data help put into context the mobility of...

Citizenship

Luis Cavalieri says many descendants of Italians waited too long to apply for citizenship recognition and questions the interest of those seeking an Italian...

Citizenship

Bergamo court refers to the Constitutional Court a question concerning the minor children of people who filed citizenship lawsuits before the 2025 reform but...