Follow Italianism

Hello, what do you want to look for?

Eat and drink

Italian historian questions the origin of pizza and generates furore in Italy

A researcher from the University of Parma also questions the origin of dishes such as carbonara, tiramisu and panettone.

Italian historian questions the origin of pizza and generates furore in Italy
Italian historian questions the origin of pizza and generates furore in Italy

Criticize the food and doubting the origin of dishes from Mediterranean peoples is not usually well received in this region of the world so attached to its gastronomic culture. Now, if this question is directed at an Italian and still raises doubts about pizza, the fight is right.

This is what the historian of University of Parma Alberto Grandi. In a interview with the newspaper “Finantial Times" Last week, Grandi, who researches the history of gastronomy and food, stated, among other things, that Italian cuisine as we know it today is actually more North American than Italian.

“While staying in Naples, the pizza was complete rubbish. But when it arrived in New York, it gained new features, especially tomato sauce, becoming the wonder we know today,” Grandi told the Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera. “Without the Italians’ trip to America, I’m sure pizza would have disappeared.”

Albert Grandi

The historian's thesis is that, in a project to create its identity, Italy “invented” origins for dishes that already existed or that emerged or were improved from the influence of other regions of the world, such as the United States and even Brazil.

“We confuse identity with roots. Our history is full of people who emigrated to America, to Brazil, to Belgium”, said the historian in the interview.

But  the idea was not at all well received among his countrymen. He was criticized by a series of politicians, and, on social media, Italian internet users call Grandi a charlatan and media man.

“This man had a miserable childhood with a family that didn't know how to cook and now he wants to rewrite history. I wonder how much the French government must be paying him to say these things”, said an Italian internet user – France and Italy often compete for the informal title of best cuisine in Europe.

ADVERTISING
Portuguese Citizenship: get yours here
A Blessed Citizenship will help you in your conquest.
Request a quote

Coldiretti, the main association of Italian producers and farmers, said it was opportunism on the part of the historian, who, for the group, wants to gain attention just at a time when Italy is trying to make its gastronomy a heritage of humanity.

Last week, the Italian Ministry of Culture presented the candidacy of Italian gastronomy for the title of UNESCO Cultural Heritage.

The proposal will be evaluated and decided by 2025. (G1)

Leave your comment:

Recommended for you

Eat and drink

Leggera Pizza Napoletana, from São Paulo, wins the top spot in the 50 Top Pizzas in Latin America ranking for the second time

Eat and drink

Accademia certified pizzerias and professionals in Brazil, consolidating the recognition of the quality of national pizza.

Destinations

Naples, the land of pizza, celebrates its 2.500th anniversary in 2025 with cultural events and historical tributes.

Eat and drink

Discover the controversy surrounding pizza stuffed with pasta, the gastronomic trend that divides opinions. Love or hate? Read all about it here!

Destinations

The 10 Italian provinces with the best quality of life in 2024. The North dominates the list; see the highlights and the worst-placed ones.

Italy in Brazil

Pizza, lasagna and parmigiana: Italian classics dominate the Brazilian palate, according to TastleAtlas; find out more

Italy in Brazil

Castelões Cantina and Pizzeria is located in the Brás neighborhood, in São Paulo.

Eat and drink

Celebrations and classic flavors are part of the imagination on the plate

Eat and drink

Research reveals the dishes that awaken feelings of happiness and comfort for Italians

Eat and drink

Research reveals surprising numbers for the pizzeria market.

Eat and drink

The differences between Brazilian and Italian pizzas: from dough to filling.

Eat and drink

Pizza is not just unanimous among Italians in restaurants: frozen food is frequently consumed.